Chapter 5: The Ally and the Cage
Manchester, Late April 2025
“I can’t define what a woman is.”
“If a man identifies as a woman, it’s OK for them to fight women in the ring.”
– an ally to all, except women
🪧 The Banner Remains
The Watchman returned to the square,
his signs now worn at the corners,
but clear as ever:
👉 “There’s no such thing as a transgender child”
👉 “Gender ideology is a cult”
He stood again not to provoke,
but to defend the vanishing lines of reality.
And it was there that he met The Ally.
She was calm. Pleasant. Certain.
Wrapped not in anger, but in the soft fabric of inclusivity.
🧍♀️ A Dialogue With No Anchors
“Do you believe a man can become a woman?”
“Yes — if that’s how they identify.”
“Should men who identify as women
be allowed to fight biological women in MMA?”
“If they say they’re women, they should be included.”
“Even if they break their bones? Even if women get concussed?”
“It’s their choice to be in that sport.”
“So is that still a women’s sport?”
“Yes… if they’re inclusive of all identities.”
“Can you define what a woman is?”
silence
“Well, not really… it’s complicated.”
She spoke kindly.
But every answer was an unraveling.
Every smile, a symptom of the spell.
🧱 The Stone Meets the Fog
The Watchman did not raise his voice.
He let the words hang —
each one a quiet hammer against illusion.
He was not arguing against a person.
He was speaking to the culture inside her.
A culture that calls itself compassionate,
but feeds women to ideology in the name of kindness.
🌪️ Elemental Reading
- Air (corrupted): Logic dissolved into slogans. Language became a mist.
- Fire (absent): No righteous anger for battered women. Only the warmth of conformity.
- Earth (erased): The physical body, female form — vanished beneath the haze of identity.
- Water (blurred): Emotions misused — empathy for ideology, but not for those harmed by it.
🧭 The Soft Tyranny of Inclusion
This was not hate.
It was worse.
It was consensual delusion.
A woman, defending the right of men
to beat other women senseless
because to question it would make her unkind.
“I just want to be inclusive,” she said.
But inclusion without limits
is how truth drowns.
✍️ And so the Watchman listened.
He asked. He waited. He held the line.
Not with fury —
but with the steady presence of someone
who remembers what a woman is.
🔷 Elemental Balance of This Chapter
“The Ally and the Cage – The Flat-Capped Watchman, Chapter 5”
- Air (Language, Ideology, Slogan Logic): 40%
- Earth (Embodiment, Physical Reality, Female Form): 25%
- Water (Emotional Confusion, Misplaced Empathy): 20%
- Fire (Will, Righteous Outrage, Moral Heat): 15%
Dominant Elements: Air (distorted) and Earth (diminished), with Water blurring and Fire suppressed
This chapter captures a civil but chilling encounter — a conversation clouded by inclusive slogans and emotional fog. Air is dominant but corrupted: logic folds into mist, and speech unmoors from meaning. Earth is present by absence — the female body, the rules of sport, the category of womanhood all erased. Water flows strangely: empathy redirected toward ideology rather than its victims. Fire, strikingly, is almost absent — there is no protective anger, no principled refusal. The Watchman stands not in fury but in clarity — remembering the boundaries the culture has forgotten.
The Daily EleMental 
Leave a comment